if only LIly chose Snape !
Open to any feedback
Seatting long and boring hours on the lessons of Potions, Charms, Transfiguration or Herbology I often think about something more interesting.
For example what could happen if Lily chose Snape instead of James Potter. I think it could be a really nice story of relations - inspiring, strong and emotional. The story when one and one gives much more when two separate things. It could might have brought Snape into the Potter family and he become softer aand more positive . May be the whole atmosphere in Hogwarts could be different, more ositive and less bullying. May be then Professor Snape could be more loyal to Dumbledore and play on his side in the fight against Voldemort. MAy be James Potter would chosen another personal journey without Lily. Who knows? So many possible variants.. I am not a great exert in all those "feelings and connections".
What? What did you say Professor? Not, I am not dreaming again , Professor I just gave my eyes s a little rest. Such an interesting lecture today!
ifIf only LIlyLily chose Snape !
SeattingSitting through long and boring hours on the lessons of lessons on Potions, Charms, Transfiguration or Herbology, I often think about something more interesting.
For example what could happenhave happened if Lily chosehad chosen Snape instead of James Potter.
The hypothetical is in the past, so it's "what could have happened" If it still has to happen / hasn't happened yet, then it's "what would happen / could happen if we did ..."
I think it could behave been a really nice story of relations - inspiring, strong and emotional.
TheA story when one and one, gives when put together, give much more whenthan two separate things.
It could might have brought Snape into the Potter family and he may have become softer aandand more positive .
May beMaybe the whole atmosphere in Hogwarts could bewould have been different, more ositivepositive and with less bullying.
"Maybe" is one word
May beMaybe then Professor Snape could bewould have been more loyal to Dumbledore and play on his side in the fight against Voldemort.
MAy beMaybe James Potter would chosenhave found another personal journey without Lily.
"choosing a journey" doesn't sound quite right.
I am not a great exertexpert in all those "feelings and connections".
Not, I am not dreaming again , Professor
I just gave my eyes s a little rest.
Overall feedback
Haha, I love the idea and the scenario! :) But, like someone else mentioned, Lily would've just joined the Snape family, not the Potters! Though maybe Snape really would have been a better person if he got what he wanted... but doesn't that mean he wasn't really that good of a person at all? 💭
It could might have brought Snape into the Potter family and he might have become softer aandand more positive.
But Lily would’ve become Lily Snape, bringing her into the Snape family, not Severus into the Potter family. Then maybe their son, Harry Snape, would’ve turned out like Draco Malfoy. :-)
Discussion
No discussion yet.
Log in to join the discussion.