atomcdismantling's avatar
atomcdismantling

Oct. 1, 2024

0
我对广东话的看法

在上篇文章里,我写到我看了三部王家卫的电影。看它们可能是我第一次接触到广东话。这些电影里大部分对话是用广东话的,而角色的内心独白使用汉语。我并没有冒犯的意思,但对我而言,广东话比汉语更加好听。比如,歌手王菲的几首歌曲有汉语版和广东话版。我觉得广东话版通常比汉语版更悦耳。不过我目前没有打算学习广东话。暂时汉语已经足够了。此外,我觉得汉语的四个声调已经很难了。广东话有更多声调,所以无法想象掌握这种语言。如果有一天我精通了汉语,可能会考虑学习它。


What I think about Cantonese

In my previous entry, I wrote about having watched three of Wong Kar-wai's films. Watching them might have been my first exposure to Cantonese. Most of the dialogue in these films is in Cantonese, while the characters' internal monologues are in Mandarin. I mean no offense, but to me, Cantonese sounds better than Mandarin. For example, several songs by the singer Faye Wong have both Mandarin and Cantonese versions. I find the Cantonese versions usually sound more pleasant. However, I don't plan to learn Cantonese at the moment. For now, Mandarin is already enough. Besides, I find the four tones of Mandarin already difficult. Cantonese has even more tones, and I can't imagine mastering such a language. If one day I become fluent in Mandarin, I might consider learning it.

Corrections

我对广东话的看法

在上篇文章里,我写到我看三部王家卫电影。

What I think about Cantonese

In my previous entry, I wrote about having watched three of Wong Kar-wai's films. Watching them might have been my first exposure to Cantonese. Most of the dialogue in these films is in Cantonese, while the characters' internal monologues are in Mandarin. I mean no offense, but to me, Cantonese sounds better than Mandarin. For example, several songs by the singer Faye Wong have both Mandarin and Cantonese versions. I find the Cantonese versions usually sound more pleasant. However, I don't plan to learn Cantonese at the moment. For now, Mandarin is already enough. Besides, I find the four tones of Mandarin already difficult. Cantonese has even more tones, and I can't imagine mastering such a language. If one day I become fluent in Mandarin, I might consider learning it.

看它们可能是我第一次接触到广东话。

这些电影里大部分对话是用广东话的,而角色的内心独白使用汉语普通话

广东话是汉语的一种方言。

我并没有冒犯的意思,但对我而言,广东话比汉语更加好听。

比如,歌手王菲的几首歌曲有汉语版和广东话版。

我觉得广东话版通常比汉语版更悦耳。

不过我目前没有打算学习广东话。

暂时汉语已经足够了。

此外,我觉得汉语的四个声调已经很难了。

广东话有更多声调,所以无法想象掌握这种语言。

如果有一天我精通了汉语,可能会考虑学习它。

Feedback

你对音律的感觉是有道理的。因为广东话根源于古代中原雅言,当时的人们更注重音调韵律。

atomcdismantling's avatar
atomcdismantling

Oct. 2, 2024

0

谢谢你的修改!我有一个问题,但不是关于我的文章。我看过你写的几篇文章,了解到你住在上海。我听说上海有一种方言叫上海话,但会说的人越来越少。是真的吗?

Tammy's avatar
Tammy

Oct. 3, 2024

1

是的。

事实上,因为信息交流和交通越来越便利,中国所有的方言都越来越少人用了。

此外,我觉得汉语的四个声调已经很难了。


This sentence has been marked as perfect!

广东话有更多声调,所以无法想象掌握这种语言。


This sentence has been marked as perfect!

如果有一天我精通了汉语,可能会考虑学习它。


This sentence has been marked as perfect!

暂时汉语已经足够了。


This sentence has been marked as perfect!

不过我目前没有打算学习广东话。


我对广东话的看法


This sentence has been marked as perfect!

在上篇文章里,我写到我看了三部王家卫的电影。


在上篇文章里,我写到我看三部王家卫电影。

What I think about Cantonese In my previous entry, I wrote about having watched three of Wong Kar-wai's films. Watching them might have been my first exposure to Cantonese. Most of the dialogue in these films is in Cantonese, while the characters' internal monologues are in Mandarin. I mean no offense, but to me, Cantonese sounds better than Mandarin. For example, several songs by the singer Faye Wong have both Mandarin and Cantonese versions. I find the Cantonese versions usually sound more pleasant. However, I don't plan to learn Cantonese at the moment. For now, Mandarin is already enough. Besides, I find the four tones of Mandarin already difficult. Cantonese has even more tones, and I can't imagine mastering such a language. If one day I become fluent in Mandarin, I might consider learning it.

看它们可能是我第一次接触到广东话。


This sentence has been marked as perfect!

这些电影里大部分对话是用广东话的,而角色的内心独白使用汉语。


这些电影里大部分对话是用广东话的,而角色的内心独白使用汉语普通话

广东话是汉语的一种方言。

我并没有冒犯的意思,但对我而言,广东话比汉语更加好听。


This sentence has been marked as perfect!

比如,歌手王菲的几首歌曲有汉语版和广东话版。


This sentence has been marked as perfect!

我觉得广东话版通常比汉语版更悦耳。


This sentence has been marked as perfect!

不过我目前没有打算学习广东话。


This sentence has been marked as perfect!

You need LangCorrect Premium to access this feature.

Go Premium